The many ways to Transparency: A typology of topics and varieties in the transparency literature

Roberto Cruz Romero

doi:10.51915/ret.286

Authors

Roberto Cruz Romero

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.51915/ret.286

Keywords:

transparency, accountability, public administration, governance, systematic review

Abstract

This article explores a sample of the literature on transparency in the 1984-2020 period through a systematic review. The sample consists of 242 works (articles, books, and book chapters) collected from different academic databases. Latent dirichlet allocation (LDA) probabilistic topic modelling – an unsupervised machine learning approach – is employed in order to classify and construct a typology of topics within the literature. This approach is complemented by a structured overview of the varieties of transparency framework and is aimed at addressing three research questions: a) What analytical approaches are identified in the literature? b) How is transparency conceptualised through such analytical approaches? And, c) where has transparency’s focus been placed in relation to an event-process framework? The findings show unequal methodological approaches, topics, and issues investigated. These insights and the novel approach utilised outline key challenges and opportunities for future transparency research.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Global Statistics

453 Views	244 Downloads
697 Total

References

AGHION, P., AKCIGIT, U., CAGÉ, J., and KERR, W. R., 2016. “Taxation, corruption, and growth”. European Economic Review, 86: 24–51.

ALATAS, S. F., 2003. “Academic Dependency and the Global Division of Labour in the Social Sciences”. Current Sociology, 51: 599–613.

ALLOA, E. and THOMÄ, D., 2018a. “Transparency: Thinking Through an Opaque Concept”. In: Transparency, Society and Subjectivity: Critical Perspectives (eds. E. ALLOA and D. THOMÄ). Cham: Springer International Publishing, 1–14.

ALLOA, E. and THOMÄ, D., eds., 2018b. Transparency, Society and Subjectivity: Critical Perspectives. 1st ed. Cham: Springer International Publishing.

ANDRADES, J., MARTINEZ-MARTINEZ, D., LARRAN, M., and HERRERA, J., 2019. “Online information disclosure in Spanish municipal-owned enterprises A study based on the compliance with transparency requirements”. Online Information Review, 43: 922–944.

ARGYROUS, G., 2012. “Evidence Based Policy: Principles of Transparency and Accountability”. Australian Journal of Public Administration, 71: 457–468.

BALL, C., 2009. “What Is Transparency?”. Public Integrity, 11: 293–308.

BANNISTER, F. and CONNOLLY, R., 2011. “The Trouble with Transparency: A Critical Review of Openness in e-Government”. Policy & Internet, 3: 1–30.

BARASSI, M. R. and Zhou, Y., 2012. “The effect of corruption on FDI: A parametric and non-parametric analysis”. European Journal of Political Economy, 28: 302–312.

BIRCHALL, C., 2021. Radical secrecy: the ends of transparency in datafied America. Minneapolis [Minnesota]: University of Minnesota Press.

BLEI, D. M., NG, A. Y., and JORDAN, M. I., 2003. “Latent dirichlet allocation”. Journal of Machine Learning Research, 3: 993–1022.

BLIND, P., K., 2014. Policy-Driven Democratization. Geometrical Perspectives on Transparency, Accountability, and Corruption. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

CHAMBERLAIN, S., 2021. “fulltext: Full text of ‘scholarly’ articles across many data sources”. Available from: https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=fulltext.

CHATWIN, M., ARKU, G., and Cleave, E., 2019. “Defining subnational open government: does local context influence policy and practice?”. Policy Sciences, 52: 451–479.

CHEN, C. and GANAPATI, S., 2021. “Do transparency mechanisms reduce government corruption? A meta-analysis”. International Review of Administrative Sciences, August: 1–16.

COLLYER, F. M., 2018. “Global patterns in the publishing of academic knowledge: Global North, global South”. Current Sociology, 66: 56–73.

CUCCINIELLO, M. and NASI, G., 2014. “Transparency for Trust in Government: How Effective is Formal Transparency?”. International Journal of Public Administration, 37: 911–921.

CUCCINIELLO, M., PORUMBESCU, G. A., and GRIMMELIKHUIJSEN, S., 2017. “25 Years of Transparency Research: Evidence and Future Directions”. Public Administration Review, 77: 32–44.

DEIGHTON-SMITH, R., 2004. “Regulatory transparency in OECD countries: Overview, trends and challenges”. Australian Journal of Public Administration, 63: 66–73.

DORN, F., GAEBLER, S., and ROESEL, F., 2021. “Ineffective fiscal rules? The effect of public sector accounting standards on budgets, efficiency, and accountability”. Public Choice.

ELLIS, C. J. and FENDER, J., 2006. “Corruption and Transparency in a Growth Model”. International Tax and Public Finance, 13: 115–149.

ERKKILÄ, T., 2020. “Transparency in Public Administration”. Oxford Research Encyclopaedia of Politics, May: 1–21.

FOX, J., 2007. “The uncertain relationship between transparency and accountability”. Development in Practice, 17: 663–671.

GANDÍA, J. L., MARRAHI, L., and HUGUET, D., 2016. “Digital transparency and Web 2.0 in Spanish city councils”. Government Information Quarterly, 33: 28–39.

GOLDRING, J., 1984. “Public Law and Accountability of Government”. Federal Law Review, 15: 1–38.

GRIMMELIKHUIJSEN, S., 2012. “Linking transparency, knowledge and citizen trust in government: an experiment”. International Review of Administrative Sciences, 78: 50–73.

GRÜN, B. and HORNIK, K., 2011. “topicmodels: An R Package for Fitting Topic Models”. Journal of Statistical Software, 40: 1-30.

GUILLAMÓN, M.D., BASTIDA, F., and BENITO, B., 2011. “The Determinants of Local Government’s Financial Transparency”. Local Government Studies, 37: 391–406.

HEALD, D., 2003. “Fiscal transparency: Concepts, measurement and UK practice”. Public Administration, 81: 723–759.

HEALD, D., 2006a. “Transparency as an Instrumental Value”. In: Transparency: The Key to Better Governance? (eds. C. HOOD and D. HEALD). Oxford: Oxford University Press, 59–73.

HEALD, D., 2006b. “Varieties of Transparency”. In: Transparency: The Key to Better Governance? (eds. C. HOOD and D. HEALD). Oxford: Oxford University Press, 25–43.

HEALD, D., 2012. “Why is transparency about public expenditure so elusive?” International Review of Administrative Sciences, 78: 30–49.

HOOD, C. and HEALD, D., eds., 2006. Transparency: The Key to Better Governance? Oxford: Oxford University Press.

IWASAKI, I. and SUZUKI, T., 2012. “The determinants of corruption in transition economies”. Economics Letters, 114: 54–60.

LEJANO, R. P., 2021. “Relationality: an alternative framework for analysing policy”. Journal of Public Policy, 41: 360–383.

LIBERATI, A., ALTMAN, D. G., TETZLAFF, J., MULROW, C., GØTZSCHE, P. C., IOANNIDIS, J. P. A., CLARKE, M., DEVEREAUX, P. J., KLEIJNEN, J., and MOHER, D., 2009. “The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate healthcare interventions: explanation and elaboration”. BMJ, 339: b2700

LINDSTEDT, C. and NAURIN, D., 2010. “Transparency is not Enough: Making Transparency Effective in Reducing Corruption”. International Political Science Review, 31: 301–332.

MAURO, P., 1995. “Corruption and Growth”. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 110: 681–712.

MEIJER, A., 2014. “Transparency”. In: The Oxford Handbook of Public Accountability (eds. M. BOVENS, R.E. GOODIN, and T. SCHILLEMANS). Oxford: Oxford University Press, 507–524.

MEIJER, A., ’T HART, P., and WORTHY, B., 2018. “Assessing Government Transparency: An Interpretive Framework”. Administration & Society, 50: 501–526.

MONTEDURO, F. and ALLEGRINI, V., 2020. “How outsourcing affects the e-disclosure of performance information by local governments”. Government Information Quarterly, 37: 101398.

NAURIN, D., 2007. “Transparency, Publicity, Accountability – The missing links”. Presented at the Delegation and Mechanisms of Accountability in the EU, Uppsala: CONNEX-RG2, 12.

PIOTROWSKI, S. J., 2012. Governmental Transparency in the Path of Administrative Reform. New York: SUNY Press.

RAWLINS, B., 2008. “Give the Emperor a Mirror: Toward Developing a Stakeholder Measurement of Organizational Transparency”. Journal of Public Relations Research, 21: 71–99.

RETHLEFSEN, M. L., KIRTLEY, S., WAFFENSCHMIDT, S., AYALA, A. P., MOHER, D., PAGE, M. J., KOFFEL, J. B., BLUNT, H., BRIGHAM, T., CHANG, S., CLARK, J., CONWAY, A., COUBAN, R., DE KOCK, S., FARRAH, K., FEHRMANN, P., FOSTER, M., FOWLER, S. A., GLANVILLE, J., HARRIS, E., HOFFECKER, L., ISOJARVI, J., KAUNELIS, D., KET, H., LEVAY, P., LYON, J., MCGOWAN, J., MURAD, M. H., NICHOLSON, J., PANNABECKER, V., PAYNTER, R., PINOTTI, R., ROSS-WHITE, A., SAMPSON, M., SHIELDS, T., STEVENS, A., SUTTON, A., WEINFURTER, E., WRIGHT, K., YOUNG, S., and PRISMA-S Group, 2021. “PRISMA-S: an extension to the PRISMA Statement for Reporting Literature Searches in Systematic Reviews”. Systematic Reviews, 10: 1–19.

SAXENA, S. and MUHAMMAD, I., 2018. “Barriers to use open government data in private sector and NGOs in Pakistan”. Information Discovery and Delivery, 46: 67–75.

SCHARPF, F. W., 1998. Interdependence and democratic legitimation. MPIfG working paper. Available from: https://www.econstor.eu/handle/10419/41689.

SCHMIDTHUBER, L., INGRAMS, A., and HILGERS, D., 2021. “Government Openness and Public Trust: The Mediating Role of Democratic Capacity”. Public Administration Review, 81: 91-109.

SCHNACKENBERG, A. K., TOMLINSON, E., and COEN, C., 2021. “The dimensional structure of transparency: A construct validation of transparency as disclosure, clarity, and accuracy in organizations”. Human Relations, 74: 1628–1660.

SILGE, J. and ROBINSON, D., 2017. Text mining with R: a tidy approach. First edition. Beijing; Boston: O’Reilly.

SOFYANI, H., RIYADH, H. A., and FAHLEVI, H., 2020. “Improving service quality, accountability and transparency of local government: The intervening role of information technology governance”. Cogent Business & Management, 7: 1–20.

SOVACOOL, B. K., WALTER, G., VAN DE GRAAF, T., and ANDREWS, N., 2016. “Energy Governance, Transnational Rules, and the Resource Curse: Exploring the Effectiveness of the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI)”. World Development, 83: 179–192.

TAI, K.-T., 2021. “Open government research over a decade: A systematic review”. Government Information Quarterly, 38: 101566.

TIMMERMANS, S. and TAVORY, I., 2012. “Theory Construction in Qualitative Research: From Grounded Theory to Abductive Analysis”. Sociological Theory, 30: 167–186.

TRANSPARENCY INTERNATIONAL and UN HABITAT, 2004. Tools to support transparency in local governance. Berlin: United Nations Human Settlements Programme.

VIJGE, M. J., METCALFE, R., WALLBOTT, L., and OBERLACK, C., 2019. “Transforming institutional quality in resource curse contexts: The extractive industries transparency initiative in Myanmar”. Resources Policy, 61: 200–209.

VILLORIA MENDIETA, M. and IGLESIAS ALONSO, A., 2017. “Developments in transparency in the Spanish municipalities: An analytical revision of the last research”. Lex Localis - Journal of Local Self-Government, 15: 411–432.

WANG, Q. and GUAN, Z., 2022. “Can Sunlight Disperse Mistrust? A Meta-Analysis of the Effect of Transparency on Citizens’ Trust in Government”. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 33: 453-467.

WILLIAMS, A., 2014. “Using the Release of Information as an Indicator of Government Transparency”. In: Corruption, Good Governance and Economic Development (eds- R.N. Ghosh and M.A.B. Siddique). Singapore: World Scientific Publishing, 25–45.

ZHAO, J. H., KIM, S. H., and DU, J., 2003. “The Impact of Corruption and Transparency on Foreign Direct Investment: An Empirical Analysis”. MIR: Management International Review, 43: 41–62.